News & Reviews Product Reviews Staff Reviews Broadway Limited Imports LLC HO scale Chesapeake & Ohio T-1 2-10-4 steam locomotive

Broadway Limited Imports LLC HO scale Chesapeake & Ohio T-1 2-10-4 steam locomotive

By Angela Cotey | July 15, 2014

| Last updated on November 3, 2020


Read this review from Model Railroader magazine

Email Newsletter

Get the newest photos, videos, stories, and more from Trains.com brands. Sign-up for email today!

BroadwayLimitedImportsHOscaleCOT12104steamlocomotive
Broadway Limited Imports HO scale C&O T-1 2-10-4 steam locomotive
A locomotive designed for both speed and power is being offered in HO scale by Broadway Limited Imports. The Chesapeake & Ohio class T-1 2-10-4 “Texas” steam locomotive, built by Lima Locomotive Works, was designed to haul long coal trains from the mines of West Virginia to the docks of Toledo, Ohio. And when it comes to the number of cars it can pull, BLI’s HO scale model rivals its prototype.

Broadway Limited’s HO scale T-1 is a handsome brute, accurately reproducing one of the most powerful two-cylinder steam locomotives ever built. The model features finely molded boiler detail and wire grab irons, and is equipped with a dual-mode Paragon2 Digital Command Control sound decoder and smoke unit.

In search of power. In 1929, the C&O wanted to develop a single locomotive that could pull long coal trains by itself from Russell, W.Va., all the way to Lake Erie. Railroad officials ran some tests with a Lima-built Erie 2-8-4 Berkshire, but it came up short in pulling power.

So the C&O designed a larger version of the Berkshire, adding a driver axle, enlarging the boiler and firebox, and increasing the drivers to 69″ diameter. Lima Locomotive Works built 40 of the new 2-10-4s for the C&O between August and November 1930.

Before long, the T-1s were hauling 160-car coal drags across Ohio almost unassisted – a job they did for nearly 20 years. They were replaced by Electro-Motive Division F7 diesels in April 1952 and scrapped by July 1953.

Removingthesmokeboxfrontrevealsthesmokeunitandmetalweight
Removing the smokebox front reveals the smoke unit and metal weight.
Appearance. The BLI model has a plastic shell over a die-cast metal weight and frame. The shell is finely molded, with crisp bolt and rivet detail, boiler bands, and sand lines. The press-fit smokebox front is removable for ­access to the smoke generator and light-emitting-diode headlight.

The body is painted an even, smooth satin black, and the smokebox is graphite. The yellow cab lettering is crisp and opaque. The tiny lettering in the builder’s plates on either side of the smokebox is clear and legible. The driver faces are painted black, while their treads, like the other wheels, are chemically blackened.

The middle set of drivers is blind, or flangeless, to allow the model to handle 22″ radius curves. Though this was typically also true of prototype ten-coupled steam loco­motives, it wasn’t on the C&O’s class T-1; instead, lateral play was designed into the driver axles and running gear to allow them to shift along curves.

T1engineersside
The engineer’s side of the T-1.
Almost all of the model’s dimensions matched those in a builder’s diagram I found in Steam Locomotive Diagrams of the Chesapeake & Ohio Railroad by ­Alvin F. Staufer (out of print). The exception is the driver diameter. Because model flanges are proportionally larger than those on the prototype, the model’s drivers must be smaller to maintain prototypical axle spacing. The model’s wheels are a scale 66″ in diameter – smaller than the prototype’s 69″, but not a significant difference. The wheels are all in gauge, and the couplers are mounted at the right height.

The engine’s two-wheel pilot and four-wheel trailing trucks are sprung to help them track on sharp curves and ­uneven trackwork. I ran the 2-10-4 through the no. 5 turnouts of our Wisconsin & Southern project layout without any trouble.

HOscaleCO2104
Road test. Since our sample was equipped with a dual-mode Paragon2 Digital Command Control sound decoder, I tested it both under direct current and DCC. I first ran it on DC, using a Model Rectifier Corp. Tech7 Ampac 760.

On our DC test track, the sound decoder started up at 7 volts, typical for a sound decoder-equipped locomotive model. Though the voltage requirements of sound ­decoders limit the usable voltage range of a decoder-equipped locomotive in DC, BLI’s T-1 is geared for smooth slow-speed performance. At 8V, the engine started moving steadily at an impressively slow 1 scale mph. It topped out at 61 scale mph at 12V, an
appropriate top speed for its prototype.

The model’s drawbar pull was also impressive, the product of traction tires on the rear axle of a nearly 11⁄2-pound engine. Our test bench’s force meter registered a drawbar pull of 10.7 ounces, or 2⁄3 of a pound. Based on our measure of 14 standard 40-foot HO scale boxcars per ounce, we judged that the HO model could pull about 150 free-rolling cars on straight and level track.

Broadway Limited Imports offers the DC Master, a device that connects between a direct-current power pack and the layout. It has four buttons that give a DC operator access to some of the functions of a BLI Blue Line or Paragon2 ­decoder. I used one to activate the bell, whistle, and air compressor sounds, as well as to adjust the sound volume.

Speaking of sounds, those produced by the dual downward-facing speakers in the tender were robust and realistic. Under DC control, steam chuffs sounded automatically, synchronized to driver rotation. Slowing the engine suddenly resulted in a brake squeal. The clank of a Johnson bar sounded when the direction was reversed. Other automatic sounds played randomly.

More sounds were available under DCC. Using the function keys on our NCE Power Cab, I triggered the bell, coupler crash, air compressor, and a realistic, powerful whistle. The decoder’s sound menu also includes ambient noises and radio cab chatter.

The engine’s performance under DCC was as smooth and powerful as under DC. The locomotive started out at 1 scale mph at speed step 1, and topped out at 65 scale mph at speed step 28. Switching the DCC system over to 128 speed steps ­offered finer slow-speed control.

Finally, I added a few drops of the supplied smoke fluid to the smokestack and flipped the slide switch to turn on the smoke generator. After a brief wait, smoke began to wisp from the stack.

Broadway Limited’s C&O class T-1 is a stellar performer. It’s a handsome, well-detailed model that can more than pull its weight on an HO scale layout.

Price: $399.99

Manufacturer
Broadway Limited Imports LLC
9 East Tower Circle
Ormond Beach, FL 32174
www.broadway-limited.com

Era: 1930 to 1953

Road numbers: 3002, 3009, 3014, 3020, and 3024, plus painted but unlettered

Features

  • All drivers powered; center set blind (flangeless)
  • Blackened metal wheels, in gauge
  • Crew figures in cab
  • Electrical pickup on first four driver axles and first, third, fourth, and sixth tender axles Five-pole, skew-wound can motor with flywheel
  • Golden-white light-emitting diode headlight and backup light
  • Kadee-compatible metal knuckle couplers, at correct height
  • Minimum radius: 22″
  • Separately applied turned-brass pop valves, whistle, and bell
  • Smoke generator synchronized to steam chuffs
  • Traction tires on rear driver axle
  • Weight: 1 lb. 15 oz. (with tender; engine only, 1 lb. 6 oz.)
  • Wire hand grabs
You must login to submit a comment