News & Reviews Product Reviews Staff Reviews Kato N scale Electro-Motive Division F2 and F3 diesel locomotives

Kato N scale Electro-Motive Division F2 and F3 diesel locomotives

By Angela Cotey | September 15, 2014

| Last updated on November 3, 2020

Read this review from Model Railroader magazine

Email Newsletter

Get the newest photos, videos, stories, and more from Trains.com brands. Sign-up for email today!

KatoNscaleElectiveMotiveDivisionF2andF3diesellocomotives
Kato N scale Elective-Motive Division F2 and F3 diesel locomotives
Electro-Motive Division’s F series diesels are perhaps the most recognized locomotives in the world. Kato USA is offering a newly tooled N scale version of the F2/early F3 diesel in two-engine sets, wearing the vivid liveries characteristic of the booming postwar era. Kato’s models are smooth-running, accurate reproductions whose crisp molding and sharp paint schemes will make them standouts on the point of any transition-era freight or passenger train.

History.
After World War II, locomotive manufacturers Alco, Baldwin, and EMD all produced four-axle, 1,500-hp cab unit diesel-electrics for freight service. Electro-Motive Division’s entry was the F3, which actually started production a year before the 1,350-hp F2. The two ­engines proved popular with railroads all across the continent, selling 1,911 units in four years, counting both A and cabless B units.

The early version of the F3 (which railfans refer to as “phase 1”) was outwardly identical to the F2; both had “chicken-wire” side grills, three side portholes, and four radiator fans in tall shrouds. Therefore, Kato can label its Chicago, Burlington & Quincy models as F2s, and its Chicago & North Western models as F3s.

Though they were soon supplanted by the more popular F7s and more powerful F9s, the reliable and versatile F2s and F3s stayed in service for decades, finally yielding to hood units like the GP35 and SD40 that offered easier maintenance and better cab visibility. A handful are still running today in museum and ­excursion service.


Once over. Depending on the road name, the engines have one of two different body shells. The Burlington and CNW body shells bear the dual roof grills of a dynamic-brake-equipped locomotive. The Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific and Atlantic Coast Line models have steam generators instead. The ACL set consists of an A unit and a cabless B booster; the other sets are two A units. In all cases, both units are powered.

The one-piece plastic body shells are crisply molded, with fine rivet and grill detail. The grab irons are molded in place, and the glazing in the side portholes is flush-mounted. The roof-­mounted horns are separate details. All the body dimensions I checked matched those on prototype diagrams printed in Model Railroader Cyclopedia: Vol. 2, Diesel Locomotives (Kalmbach Publishing, out of print).

The paint jobs on all four road names are crisp and accurate, with sharp color separation, unbroken lines, and straight, legible lettering. The paint schemes and placement of details matched prototype photos that I found in books in Kalmbach Publishing’s David P. Morgan ­Memorial Library. As is the usual case with Kato, the ­locomotives come equipped with magnetic knuckle couplers that need to have their trip pins installed by the modeler. This is a simple task with a pair of ­needle-nosed pliers. The rear couplers are truck-mounted to improve the models’ performance on tight curves. Both sets of couplers on all our test samples were mounted at the correct height.

AlightingprintedcircuitboardtopsthelocomotivesmetalframeDigitraxMRCandTCSmakeboardreplacementDCCdecodersforthismodel
A lighting printed-circuit board tops the locomotive’s metal frame. Digitrax, MRC, and TCS make board-replacement DCC decoders for this model
I removed the shell to inspect the model’s frame and mechanism. The ­motor is nestled in the middle of the one-piece, cast-metal frame that gives the model most of its weight. The frame is topped by a lighting printed-circuit board (PCB), and on the A unit, a one-piece molded black plastic cab interior. Snapping the cab out of its plastic mount and removing a plastic tab in the center of the PCB allows the lighting board to be removed for replacement with a Digital Command Control decoder. Train Control Systems and Digitrax offer drop-in motor and lighting decoders designed to replace the PCB. We installed Model Rectifier Corp. no. 0001957 sound decoders in the Burlington locomotives. (See the June 2012 installment of DCC Corner for an installation of this decoder in an earlier Kato F unit.) We also used these locomotives on our upcoming N scale CB&Q project layout, which will appear in MR starting in January 2015.
KatoNscaleEMDFunit
Road test. I tested the Rock Island locomotives on our test track using a Model Rectifier Corp. Tech2 direct-current power pack. Since the mechanisms in both locomotives are identical, I tested them individually rather than as a pair.

Each engine ran smoothly and quietly, starting at less than 2V. The models are geared for speed, though, topping out at more than 200 scale mph. The highest available gearing on the prototype yielded a top speed of 102 mph. Even at full voltage, motor noise was minimal.

I also placed both engines about six inches apart on our eight-foot test track and ran them back and forth to test how they’d run together. Though the two models moved at slightly different speeds, the difference was not significant. These ­engines should run smoothly when coupled together.

The models each have two headlights, both illuminated by the same light-emitting diode (LED). The lights came on when running forward and turned off in reverse, which though not prototypical, does prevent the arguably worse error of having the rear unit’s headlight on in a two-engine lashup.

Our test-bench force meter registered a pulling power of .64 ounces, equivalent to 15 N scale freight cars on straight and level track. Since these locomotives are meant to be run as a pair, and both are powered, that adds up to a respectable length of 30 cars. To test how the engines handled curves and turnouts, I ran the decoder-equipped Burlington units on our project layout. The set moved a 10-car train through 13″-radius curves and no. 6 turnouts flawlessly.

An icon. Three-quarters of a century after the first F units rolled out of the shops, EMD’s covered wagons remain icons of North American railroading. ­Kato’s version would be a worthy addition to any N scale engine house.

Price: $170 (A-B set), $175 (two A units)

Manufacturer
Kato USA
100 Remington Road
Schaumburg, IL 60173
www.katousa.com

Road names: Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific (F2 A-A set); Atlantic Coast Line (F2 A-B set); Chicago, Burlington & Quincy (F2 A-A set); and Chicago & North Western (F3 A-A set).

Era: 1945 (F3) or 1946 (F2) to late 1970s, as decorated

Features

  • A-A or A-B sets available, depending on road name
  • Blackened metal wheelsets (in gauge) with all-wheel drive and electrical pickup
  • Cab interior and window glazing
  • Directional light-emitting-diode headlight (A units only)
  • Dynamic brakes and/or steam generator, as appropriate
  • Five-pole, skew-wound motor with dual brass flywheels
  • Kato couplers (at correct height) with modeler-applied trip pins
  • Minimum radius: 9.75″
  • Molded-in grab irons
  • Weight: 3.1 ounces each
You must login to submit a comment