News & Reviews Product Reviews Staff Reviews Walthers’ HO scale New York Central 1948 20th Century Limited 4-4-2 Pullman sleeper

Walthers’ HO scale New York Central 1948 20th Century Limited 4-4-2 Pullman sleeper

By Angela Cotey | May 22, 2009

| Last updated on November 3, 2020

Email Newsletter

Get the newest photos, videos, stories, and more from Trains.com brands. Sign-up for email today!

The newest entry in Walthers’ series of HO scale passenger trains is the 1948 edition of the New York Central’s 20th Century Limited, and the first car in the set is this smooth-sided 4-4-2 Pullman sleeper. With accurate details, it gets the series off to a strong start.

Prototype. Pullman actually built these plan 4069B 4-4-2 (4 bedroom, 4 compartment, 2 drawing room) cars for the 1938 edition of the Century, at which time they carried names in the Imperial series and had light gray sides, dark gray window bands, and full skirting. The NYC had the 10-year-old cars refurbished (including removing the skirts) and repainted with dark gray sides and a light gray window band for the 1948 Century. At that time they received new names in the Bridge series. The cars did carry full-width diaphragms for the 1938 train and at the introduction of the 1948 train, but those did not survive for long.

Modelers who want to depict the Century precisely will want different numbers of each sleeping car depending on the year modeled.

The model. Though Walthers has offered a smooth-side 4-4-2 in HO scale for several years, this is an all-new car with subtly different window placement and substantial differences in the underframe. It also has model 43-R triple-bolster roller-bearing trucks, which are correct for this car. The cars that were new for the 1948 Century used 41-C-11 trucks.

The 43-R trucks look good, though detail-oriented modelers will want to drill through the large holes on either side of the springs. The car doesn’t roll especially well because of the metal-on-metal contact between the sideframes and the axles. You’ll also want to lubricate the axle ends with low-viscosity plastic-compatible oil, as outlined in the instructions. The trucks do pick up electricity, but the car isn’t lighted; a separate lighting kit (Walthers no. 1049) is available for $11.98. To remove the roof to install lighting, twist the car gently until some of the clips snap out of the slots in the skeleton frame.

The construction of this car will be familiar to modelers with other Walthers passenger cars – a styrene plastic skeleton frame with snap-on styrene sides, ends, underframe, and roof. The interior is also molded styrene, and the underframe comes with all the key details added. Adding car name decals and installing and painting handrails are left up to the purchaser. One switch from earlier cars is that the Century cars have all-metal Proto Max knuckle couplers in the traditional size, not scale size. The flush-mounted windows don’t have painted frames. The car matches the dimensions on a Pullman floor plan closely.

The paint on our sample was smooth and the (gray) striping/lettering has white edging, which is correct for the period. One of the end-of-car road names was slightly out of alignment. The dark gray paint has a different tint than that on earlier Walthers NYC gray cars. Walthers discovered a set of the original Dupont paint chips and matched that paint for these cars.

With this 4-4-2, Walthers has added another important streamlined car to its line. The Atlantic Coast Line, Canadian National, Illinois Central, and Pennsylvania RR had Imperial cars. And just like on the prototype, I’m sure they’ll find a home on many HO scale lines.

HO scale Pullman sleeper
Price: $64.98
Manufacturer
Wm. K. Walthers Inc.
P.O. Box 3039
Milwaukee, WI 53201
www.walthers.com
Road names: New York Central, undecorated
Features:
36″ metal wheelsets with RP-25 contour, correctly gauged
Detailed underframe
Flush-mounted windows
Metal knuckle couplers with coil springs in swinging boxes, at correct height
Modeler-installed car name decals and handrails
Weight: 7 ounces (Correct per NMRA RP-20.1)

11 thoughts on “Walthers’ HO scale New York Central 1948 20th Century Limited 4-4-2 Pullman sleeper

  1. I am aminly PRR, but do have interchange passenger rails where
    both NYC & PRR run parallel – somewhat along the Chicago side by side of the 20th Century & Broadway back in prewar days. The
    ever rising cost of all phases must be a consideration – also the need for higher radius of trackage…..to bad mfg can't do modifications to allow a bit smaller radius, and hold the line on $$$

  2. I agree this car is well done. It is the best of the four full sleepers they have shipped so far. I hope they do this 4-4-2 in the correct 1938 paint scheme with full skirts. I also hope they sell the 43-R trucks as spares so I can replace the trucks on some of my other Walthers sleepers that used them. The only issue I have with this car is the price. For this price the car should include hand rails, lighting, window treatments and colored furniture.

  3. I think that for Walthers they are fine cars, but for the price they should come with the lighting kit as well. I'm also suprise that the modeler has to put on the decals and handrail. It is funny to me that with all the "research" that went into these fine cars, Walthers didn't had decals for each different model. Oh well, what can one expect for a measly 64$…

  4. I like the Walthers passenger cars and have about 8 of the Budd cars. Just wish that Walthers would pay the Chinese a bit more and have them install handrails and apply decals. Since we're now in the "ready to run" world of model railroading, this would be nice.

  5. Personally, I would like Walthers to issue these cars and other 20th Century cars where applicable, in Southern Pacific schemes(and other Railroads), both in the SP two-tone gray and the later red and silver. SP had similar cars on the pre-WW II and post-war 'Lark', 'Cascade', and 'Golden State' trains. Walthers could considerably increase their sales by doing so. In fact the Rock Island used the 'Shore' lounge cars on the Golden State, after the NYC deleted them from the 'Century".

  6. The Walthers passenger cars look nice when assembled together in a complete train but the new prices are getting too high for the level of detail and assembly required. In my oppinion, they should be fully assembled with lighting installed for this price range if they wish to keep pace with the current competition offerings. I do like the commitment to authenticity that Walthers has continued to pursue in this passenger car and other model offerings.

  7. I do not have this car yet,but at the price I do not think I will.
    If wathers keeps raising prices,nobody will buy.

  8. The car is very good. But when you add the Pullman name decal, how do you get the same luster as the car side? I would hate to have to disassemble and re-spray the entire car with a clear satin finish. Disguising the decal sheen with weathering won't do for the 20th Century! Anyone know how to really match Walther's finish. (I already checked and Walthers doesn't know either.)

  9. Michael,
    As far as hiding the decals, I've had pretty good luck with Microscale clear satin finish, applied using an airbrush. It takes very little clear to hide the decals, so I don't disassemble the car. (I do mask the window area.)
    Thanks for reading MR,
    Terry

  10. I agree with the modelers at my club in Stongsville Ohio, for this price the hand rails and lighting should be mounted on and in the cars. I do find the quality high in these cars look very good. I still find the roof very hard to remove without breaking one or more of the tabs, could be an easier way of doing this. I have one car of eight done with the seats upholstery and painting and with hand grabs .

You must login to submit a comment