News & Reviews Product Reviews Staff Reviews Accurail HO AAR 70-ton triple hopper is a nearly universal transition-era freight car

Accurail HO AAR 70-ton triple hopper is a nearly universal transition-era freight car

By Angela Cotey | November 25, 2005

| Last updated on November 3, 2020


Reviewed in the January 2006 issue

Email Newsletter

Get the newest photos, videos, stories, and more from Trains.com brands. Sign-up for email today!

Accurail HO AAR 70-ton triple hopper
Accurail HO AAR 70-ton triple hopper
This AAR 70-ton offset-side hopper from Accurail is a creatively designed and well-executed model of a very common freight car of the steam and steam-diesel transition eras. The model is an accurately scaled representation of a car built to the AAR standard of 1935.

Production of the prototype cars began in the late 1930s and continued until at least 1960. The total number built reached into the tens of thousands. Many of these 70-toncapacity hoppers were rebuilt and remained in service well into the 1970s – it’s probably as close to a “universal” hopper car as railroading will ever see.

The car’s body bolsters, fine stirrup steps, and coupler boxes are made of durable acetal plastic.
Accurail’s new model features two clever design features that help make it look good and also well suited for operation. The first feature is that the upper surfaces of the slope sheets are actually a separate piece. The metal weights are concealed in between these and the main car body. This design results in a nicely detailed interior and a realistic underside, but the weight of the car is 2.75 ounces, which is 1 ounce under the National Model Railroad Association’s recommended practice of 1 ounce plus ½-ounce per inch of length.

The second feature is that the steps, bolsters, and draft-gear pieces are injection-molded in a flexible acetal plastic. The strength of this material allowed Accurail to render the steps very finely yet keep them robust enough to withstand normal handling. Well done!

While the instructions state that cement isn’t required to hold the end braces in place, I found a few dabs of Microscale Kristal Kleer helped hold them while I added the end frame/bolster assemblies.

The car comes with Accumate couplers, sharply detailed one-piece AAR Type Y trucks, and one-piece plastic wheelsets. The axles on three of our four sets of wheels were bent enough that while the flanges were in gauge at some points, at others they were too narrow in gauge, and at others they were too wide in gauge. (Accurail will replace any defective parts.)

The paint on our B&O sample was smoothly applied, with an even sheen, and the white lettering was crisp and opaque.

To me, a quality kit is one that’s a pleasure to assemble and that results in a freight car you’ll be happy to put on your layout. This new Accurail offset-side hopper is indeed a quality kit, and I can recommend it without hesitation.

HO AAR triple hopper

Price: $10.98 each

Manufacturer
Accurail Inc.
P.O. Box 278
Elburn, IL 60119

Description
Easy plastic kit

Road names: Baltimore & Ohio; Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe; Chicago & North Western; Missouri Pacific; Pittsburgh & Lake Erie; Soo Line (dark red); Southern Pacific (T&NO); and undecorated. Data-only cars are available painted black, mineral red, and oxide red

You must login to submit a comment