News & Reviews Product Reviews Staff Reviews Athearn Trains HO scale Electro-Motive SD70ACe diesel locomotive

Athearn Trains HO scale Electro-Motive SD70ACe diesel locomotive

By Angela Cotey | December 14, 2010

| Last updated on November 3, 2020

Read this review from Model Railroader

Email Newsletter

Get the newest photos, videos, stories, and more from Trains.com brands. Sign-up for email today!

MRR-PR0211_01
Athearn Trains HO scale Electro-Motive SD70ACe diesel locomotive
This HO scale SD70ACe has the fine detail of a museum-quality brass model. The plastic ready-to-run model features many roadname-specific detail parts. The Athearn Genesis SD70ACe is also available with a factory-installed SoundTraxx Tsunami Digital Command Control (DCC) decoder.

To meet strict emissions standards imposed by the Environmental Protection Agency in 2005, General Motors Electro-Motive Division designed the SD70ACe, which EMD based on its earlier SD70MAC. The biggest improvement in the SD70ACe is its 16-710G3C-2 4,300-hp diesel engine that delivers 10 percent more horsepower with 50 percent fewer emissions.

For more information see in the November 2004 Model Railroader. The Athearn SD70ACe’s dimensions match the drawing in that article. Athearn also makes an SD70M-2.

The model. Our review samples came in BNSF, Kansas City Southern, and Union Pacific liveries. We tested BNSF no. 9210. The prototype was part of an order for 200 SD70ACes delivered in 2008. The model’s paint scheme and the placement of lettering and warning stencils match prototype photos.

MRR-PR0211_03
The SD70ACes feature roadname-specific headlights and other details.
The plastic model features many roadname-specific details, including the correct headlight. All the handgrabs are made of formed wire. The many other separately applied details include sand lines and see-through grills.
SD70ACe2
The well-detailed cab interior includes an event recorder.
The cab roof is held on by magnets. Removing the roof reveals a detailed cab interior. The seats and controls for the engineer and fireman as well as the brakeman’s seat are molded in brown plastic. There’s a separately applied event recorder mounted above the windshield.

After removing the front and rear coupler boxes, I removed two screws at each end of the fuel tank. I could then lift off the body shell.

SD70ACe
The printed-circuit board on the DC version of the SD70ACe is mounted above the motor and brass flywheels.
The motor and flywheels sit in the center of the chassis. Two shafts transfer power to gearboxes over each truck.
 
The SoundTraxx Tsunami DCC decoder is mounted on a plastic base that fits over the motor. A speaker rests vertically in its housing just behind the cab.
HO scale SD70ACe
Performance. On our DC test track, the SD70ACe began moving at 8 volts and accelerated to a top speed of 105 mph, which is a lot more than the 70 mph top speed of the prototype.

I tested the model in DCC with a Model Rectifier Corp. Prodigy Advance system. The model moved smoothly throughout its speed range, accelerating to 73 scale mph, which is close to the prototype’s top speed.

When I set the decoder to 128 speed steps, the locomotive moved jerkily in speed step 1. I then set the starting voltage (CV2) to a value of 5. The model then crept along smoothly in speed step 1 at just under 2 scale mph.

Using a DCC system, I changed the locomotive’s long address without difficulty. I also set up a consist using two Athearn SD70ACes. The locomotives pulled a train through an 18″ radius curve as well as through turnouts. The sounds and lights remained constant.

Sounds. In DC the sounds and lights came on at 7.5 volts. Most of the sound effects in DC mode are automatic. The bell turns on until the model starts moving and a grade-crossing signal sounds when the direction switch is quickly flipped. These automatic effects can be shut off, but this requires a DCC system to program the decoder.

When used with a DCC system, the decoder features many programmable configuration variables (CVs) that allow you to customize the volume level of individual sound effects. The decoder also has a built-in equalizer. Extensive user manuals are available as free downloads at www.athearn.com.

In DCC you can fine-tune the engine sounds. In automatic notching you can set the decoder to increase and decrease rpms according to the number of speed steps. You can use manual notching by setting CV116 to a value of 0. The decoder in the Athearn model is different than the aftermarket Tsunami, so you’ll need to set CV43 to a value of 8, and CV44 to a value of 32. Then you can use functions 9 and 10 to increase and decrease the rpms independently from the model’s speed.
Other user-triggered functions in DCC include the bell and long and short whistle blasts. You can also turn the non-flashing ditch lights on and off using function 5.

The Tsunami DCC decoder makes this HO diesel sound as good as it looks. The Athearn Genesis SD70ACe is an exceptional model of a modern workhorse.

Price: $289.98 (DCC sound), $189.98 (DC no sound)

Manufacturer
Athearn Trains
2883 E. Spring St., Suite 100
Long Beach, CA 90806
www.athearn.com

Era: 2005 to present

Road names (multiple road numbers): BNSF, Kansas City Southern, Union Pacific (flag scheme). Union Pacific Heritage schemes: Missouri Pacific, Western Pacific. Undecorated versions (BNSF, KCS, and UP) are available.

Features

  • All-wheel drive and electrical pickup
  • DCC socket accepts eight- or nine-pin decoder
  • Dual-mode SoundTraxx Tsunami DCC sound decoder (DCC version only)
  • Five-pole skew-wound motor with brass flywheels
  • Metal wheels in gauge
  • McHenry scale operating knuckle couplers at correct height
  • Weight: 1 pound 11⁄2 ounces
You must login to submit a comment