News & Reviews Product Reviews Staff Reviews Athearn Trains HO scale UP gas turbine

Athearn Trains HO scale UP gas turbine

By Angela Cotey | October 15, 2009

| Last updated on November 3, 2020


Read this review from Model Railroader magazine

Email Newsletter

Get the newest photos, videos, stories, and more from Trains.com brands. Sign-up for email today!

Athearn Trains HO scale UP gas turbine
Athearn Trains HO scale UP gas turbine
The distinctive grid of air intakes on the sides of the body make Athearn’s new locomotive model immediately recognizable. The Union Pacific bought 10 gas-turbine-electric locomotives from General Electric between 1952 and 1953, putting them in charge of long-haul freights in the western Rocky Mountains. Athearn’s model is a faithful reproduction of this first generation of gas turbines. Standout features include a dual-flywheel drivetrain, see-through walkways, wire grab irons, and an articulated mechanism that lets this 11-inch-long locomotive negotiate 18″-radius curves.

A new idea. After World War II, the Union Pacific was shopping for the next big idea in locomotives. To minimize maintenance costs, the railroad sought a high-horsepower locomotive that could take the place of smaller units in multiple. General Electric, which had success with turbines in aircraft, suggested a turbine-powered locomotive.

Nicknamed “Big Blow” due to the turbines’ jet-like exhaust, UP no. 50, a prototype gas-turbine locomotive started extensive testing on the railroad in July 1949. After testing no. 50 for nearly two years and more than 100,000 miles, the UP ordered 10 more of the 4,500-hp units in March 1951. But unlike the double-ended no. 50, nos. 51-60 were single-ended, allowing a slightly larger fuel tank.

Fuel capacity was an issue in operation of the gas-turbines. They drank fuel at a rate nearly double that of a similar-sized diesel. However, the turbines were still economical, because they ran on bunker “C” oil, a cheap and abundant by-product of oil refining. In 1955, the UP added a 22,000-gallon fuel tender to extend the range of the gas-turbines.

The design underwent a number of changes, even during the production run. The turbines, which required a constant flow of fresh, cool air to run at top efficiency, worked poorly when run at slow speeds in tunnels. Hot exhaust gases would back up and get sucked back into the turbine. A new, backward-angled exhaust stack helped eliminate this problem.

The first-generation turbines took in air through square panels on the sides of the carbody, protected by stainless steel Farr grills. In 1953, the intakes were moved to the roof, and the Farr grills were removed. Our sample, numbered 54, includes the angled exhaust, roof-mounted air intake housing, capped front side grills, and fuel tender of a post-1955 unit. Other road numbers have different details, such as no. 51’s Farr grills.

The Union Pacific’s venture into gas-turbine locomotives ended in 1970, as demand from the nation’s growing plastics industry made the once-cheap bunker “C” fuel oil less cost-effective.

UP added oil tenders in 1955. Athearn's has a backup light.
UP added oil tenders in 1955. Athearn’s has a backup light.
Keeping up appearances. The Athearn gas turbine is a sharp looking model, with an abundance of wire grab irons, etched-metal grills, and molded-in details adding to its realism. Etched-metal wipers are fixed to the windshields; the engineer’s control stand includes a throttle lever. The nose-mounted Mars light has both red and white lenses, though only the white light illuminates. (The lighting bracket under the hood has a space to add a microbulb for the red light in case a modeler chooses to add a Digital Command Control decoder that supports its operation.)

The Armour Yellow and Harbor Mist Gray paint on our sample is smooth and even. The fine black outlines on the red “Union Pacific” and number 54 are crisp and perfectly aligned. The red stripes on the top and bottom of the yellow section of the carbody are not the same glossy, opaque red as the lettering, though, and the overlap of the gray and red is visible.

The plastic body shell’s tooling is impressive, with finely molded details. The model’s major dimensions match those on prototype construction drawings reproduced in Thos. R. Lee’s definitive book Turbines Westward.

The model’s knuckle couplers are at the correct height, but their trip pins hung too low. I easily adjusted them with a pair of Kadee trip-pin pliers.

An inside look. Removing four screws that flank the trucks allowed me to lift the plastic shell off the one-piece, cast-metal chassis. The five-pole can motor and its turned brass flywheels are in the middle of the frame’s central tower, under a clear plastic plate. This is a good idea, as it protects the moving parts from dust that might be drawn into the body through the open exhaust vents directly above.

On either end of the frame are two 1.2″ spaces for the installation of speakers, with sound holes milled into the base above the end trucks. There are DCC decoder plugs on the printed-circuit boards in the back of the locomotive. A number of manufacturers, including QSI Solutions and SoundTraxx, offer or are planning sound decoders for the Athearn gas-turbine models.

Plastic universal drive shafts connect the motor to gearboxes on the two inboard trucks. The two sets of trucks pivot at this gearbox, which is above the locomotive’s third and sixth axles. Pivoting cast-metal plates extend from the inboard trucks to the outboard trucks. Spring-loaded screws attached to the end of each plate ride in slots in the ouboard trucks. The outboard trucks can float and pivot over a broad range of motion, which lets the nearly foot-long locomotive negotiate 18″-radius curves. The model would look better on broader curves, though.

Weighing in. The engine tips the scales at nearly two pounds, not counting the tender. This provides the model with plenty of traction, despite the fact that only the four inboard axles are powered.

The Athearn model’s headlights lit and its five-pole, skew-wound motor started turning at just over 1 volt (V). The locomotive rolled smoothly at 1.4V, at a scale speed of 1 mph. At 12V the locomotive reached a top speed of 73 scale mph. This is only slightly faster than the top speed of 69 mph listed for prototype no. 50 in the 1950-52 Simmons-Boardman Locomotive Cyclopedia of American Practice.

Through all its speed tests, the model’s drive train operated smoothly and quietly. The unit’s weight and two flywheels added a momentum effect when starting and stopping the locomotive.

With Athearn’s new model, UP fans can keep the “Big Blows” rolling for years to come.

HO scale UP gas turbine
Price: With tender, $299.98; without tender, $229.98; tender alone, $89.98

Manufacturer
Athearn Trains
2883 E. Spring St., Suite 100
Long Beach, CA 90806
www.athearn.com

Road numbers: (all Union Pacific) with tender, 54 and 58; without tender, 51 and 60; tender not numbered

Era: 1952-62 (nos. 51, 54); 1953-64 (no. 58); 1953-63 (no. 60)

Features
All-wheel electrical pickup on locomotive (no pickup on tender); eight-wheel drive
Backup light on tender
Detailed cab interior
Eight- and nine-pin DCC decoder sockets
Five-pole, skew-wound can motor with dual brass flywheels
Interchangeable nose trim (above pilot)
McHenry plastic magnetic knuckle couplers at correct height
Minimum radius: 18″
RP-25 contour metal wheels in gauge
Weight: (Engine only) 1 pound 14 ounces. (Engine and tender) 2 pounds 2 ounces

You must login to submit a comment