News & Reviews Product Reviews Video: Athearn Genesis HO scale class Z-8 Challenger

Video: Athearn Genesis HO scale class Z-8 Challenger

By Angela Cotey | June 20, 2017

| Last updated on February 11, 2021

This HO scale 4-6-6-4 steam locomotive from Athearn Trains includes a SoundTraxx Tsunami DCC decoder

Email Newsletter

Get the newest photos, videos, stories, and more from Trains.com brands. Sign-up for email today!

Check out a superdetailed Northern Pacific class Z-8 Challenger as it makes a run on the Model Railroader staff’s HO scale Milwaukee, Racine & Troy layout. This Athearn Genesis steam locomotive model features a SoundTraxx Tsunami Digital Command Control (DCC) decoder.

18 thoughts on “Video: Athearn Genesis HO scale class Z-8 Challenger

  1. Upon further review; the chuff sounds must be from a wrongly coded decoder. Someone may have put the light logging decoder instead of the articulated one. Going at any speed above a crawl the sound was that of either a six-cylinder Shay or a runaway sewing machine.

  2. Great looking locomotive. It’s nice to see the axles are in the center of the drivers – no noticeable wobble! The sound though? Is there no baffle on the speaker? And the chuffs seemed out of synch.

  3. I have read that the second batch of models are equipped with Loksound decoders. If so, does anyone have experience with the sound quality of those models?

  4. I have to agree with everyone else. The sound was lacking big time! The engine and tender look fine but there’s too big a gap between the two. Are there multiple holes in the draw bar for short and long radius curves? Maybe that can be fixed.

  5. Athearn must change that sound decoder ,it is toy-sound , pitty for this big power steamer ,Running seems ok to me .

  6. What a poor sound system, both the whistle and the chuffing. Too bad manufacturers still make locos that between the boiler and the wheels, you get a good view of what’s on the other side. There should be some light baffle like real locos without lots of open space on a huge loco like this. Just some foam would be better than this. Other manufacturers generally do the same, not just Athearn.

  7. That is the worst example of a sound fitted loco that I have ever come across. The noises (and that is all they are) bear no relationship to a steam locomotive’s charismatic rhythms. A nice looking loco spoiled by the sound. A good case for cutting the wires to the speaker. A great shame.

  8. This is a great locomotive for operation on a layout. It pulls well (30+ cars on my layout with a 3% ruling grade). Last fall I ran mine for 4 hours continuous at an open house. No problems and no derailments

    The details do not match those on my brass NP Challengers. However, this seems like it will be a reliable engine for operating sessions.

    Good value for the price!.

  9. From my perspective, the sound was generally not good. Interesting that Dan thought the whistle was ok –
    I thought was particularly bad.
    Seemed to run well, though.

  10. Looks great and the sound for the bell and whistle and generator sounded ok. The exhaust chuff sounded more like a ratchet wrench or something though, anything but a steam locomotive. There needs to be a way to develop a bigger speaker or something to allow the deep bass sound needed for a proper sounding onboard steam chuff.

  11. I would agree with Daniel Rawers about the chuff sound. I also think they might have been out of sync (i.e. more chuffs than wheel revolutions).

You must login to submit a comment